AI Deep DiveNo. 371
Why your AI product has SaaS pricing and utility-grade costs
Business Analytics Newsletter
· 10 min read
Cheaper by the Token, Costlier by the Task: Inside AI’s Quiet Margin Crisis
What You’ll Learn From This Edition
Why the widely cited “token prices have collapsed” statistic can be true at the same time AI companies report worse gross margins than the software they’re replacing
The specific mechanism, agentic multi-step workloads, currently outpacing the price-deflation curve, with the 2026 numbers behind it
Why one AI lab’s margin can climb from 38% to over 70% in a year while its own customers’ margins compress, using the same usage growth as the cause
A framework for telling whether a given AI cost behaves like software (falling toward zero at scale) or like a utility (scaling with usage)
How to reread a vendor’s pricing page, a startup’s unit economics slide, or an earnings call transcript once you’re looking for this distinction
What Uber’s four-month AI budget and Microsoft’s internal Claude Code cancellation actually tell you about where this is heading
Table of Contents
Executive Summary
Deep Dive in One Sentence
Why This Topic Matters Now
The Big Question
The Conventional Narrative
What’s Really Happening
The Economics Behind the Shift
Winners and Losers
Second-Order Effects
Strategic Implications
Mental Model of the Week
Key Takeaways
Closing Thought
Executive Summary
Token prices have fallen by roughly two to three orders of magnitude since 2022, yet gross margins on AI-native products are falling too, from a SaaS-standard 70 to 90 percent range down toward the low 50s in 2026.
The reason: agentic workflows consume far more tokens per completed task than the falling price curve accounts for, so total spend rises even as the unit price drops.
The margin math splits by layer. Model owners are capturing rising margin from usage growth. The companies building on top of those models are absorbing the rising cost as COGS.
This is already visible in the market: Uber, Microsoft, Cursor, GitHub, and Salesforce have all had to publicly reprice or restrict AI usage in 2026 because flat pricing collided with real, scaling compute costs.
The strategic implication: AI-native software should be underwritten like a utility with a real marginal cost, not a software business with a marginal cost of zero.
Members only
This is a Daily Edition
Members get the full analysis every publishing day, by email and on the web.
8 more minutes of this edition
Membership opens soon, at $89 a year or $9 a month. See what members get
Get the free edition meanwhile
The Free Edition by email, plus the opening of every Elite Edition.
Email sign-ups open soon
Every Free Edition is already open on the web, and the feed works in any reader.
Already a member? Sign in
Reader sign-in opens very soon, together with free and paid subscriptions.